I do have a 3tb seagate though since the external update and its worked as expected. Seagate expansion or wd mybook for external hard drive. I never have bought an assembled external drive but have two seagates in enclosures and 4 in desktop machines. It would be safest to have the files in two places. Western digital or seagate goflex 1tb external hdd. Unlike seagate s goflex desk, the my book essential doesnt have an option for interfaces. Jul 08, 2014 hgst deskstar nas wd red anything by seagate. Halo pal, both disks are windows 10 compatible and will work on usb 2. Unlike seagates goflex desk, the my book essential doesnt have an option for interfaces. The seagate thunderbolt adapter driver is only needed if you are using 3tb or 4tb drives with the thunderbolt adapter and plan to change drives with other goflex adapters such as usb or firewire. Western digital drive vs hitachi drive vs seagate server hard drives in a brief amount of words we will be placing below. It has dozens of popular alternatives in the same price range, such as wd my book or wd my passport for mac.
Seagate goflex 3tb western digital my book essential 3tb usb 3. But if you still ask me, from my experience i would say seagate. Going by general consensus, wd is the better brand, but ive had no trouble with my seagate barracuda drive ive had for about 4 years now, and one of my wd caviar blacks has died on me after only. Seagate nasworks hence i would not actually want to use a nearline disk in.
It was a 5 platter, 3tb seagate barracuda xt inside an external goflex desk chassis. This means if you take the drive out of the enclosure and connect it directly via sata or put it in another enclosure, the data you read will be scrambled and unusable. By contrast, the best seagate can muster is 10tb of storage from the singledrive backup plus hub amazon or expansion desktop. Seagate got the delicate act of balancing portability with capacity better than some, but not as good as others. Which is better wd passport ultra 2tb or seagate backup plus. I have a seagate freeagent goflex 1tb external drive. Neither requires external power sources, but your usb hub might need to be powered if you have any other highdraw devices like another disk. Weve chosen the wd passport as our winner in this category because of its small, thin size. I also own 2 1tb western digital my book essentials.
The wd blacks have 64mb cache compaired to seagates 32mb this in theory helps speed up the wd read and write speeds with smaller files, like i said it does perform well on benchmarks but dont expect a massive difference. May 16, 2007 so im in the market for a new external hd to backup my files obviously and two specific drives came to my attention. Western digital drive vs hitachi drive vs seagate server hard. Wd mybook essential enclosure and non wd replacement drive. Considering getting a 3gb external hard drive for backup and storage. Out of all the options, to me that seems like the best one. Seagate vs western digital hddwhich one is better pc. In 16 years i had two drive fail, both were wd models, this was a few years ago and they were 120250gb ones, i think. But i am having an issue of it not finding my seagate goflex network drive as. Western digital wins out when it comes to larger capacities, offering its my book duo with 20tb of storage in either a raid 0 or raid 1 configuration, along with plenty of connectivity. In my experience, seagate hardware has a much higher failure rate than wd or hgst drives. Effective december 31st, 2018, remote access, including the premium service, will no longer be available. Up front is a hinged door hiding the goflex drive bay, on the side a single usb 2. They are built to be the cheapest, and their low quality build shows in their desinlgns.
My book drives encrypt everything on the drive even if you dont specify a password. Goflex desk external drive support seagate support us. The seagate thunderbolt adaptor driver is only needed if you are using 3 tb or 4 tb drives with the thunderbolt adaptor and plan to change drives with other goflex adaptors such as usb or firewire. Synology does not guarantee the compatibility with thirdparty products and peripherals. Ive been able to play my files from my seagate goflex network drive via media library thru axentraserver. Wd my passport ultra vs seagate backup plus slim vs toshiba vs hgst vs samsung january 1, 2015 storage hdd, portable, usb3 pretzel it is this authors opinion that 2015 should be the year of the backup. Wd my book essentials 1tb 12v replacement power supply.
Seagate drives have by far the highest rate of failure of any hard drive manufacturer. Which external hard drive is better, seagate or wd. And it doesnt have to be plugged in to an outlet, so you can use this on the go. Nov 27, 2014 wd my cloud 2tb personal cloud storage from a trusted and recognizable hard drive brand western digital comes this xbox looking quality lowcost entrylevel network storage device. Essential elements freeagent goflex freeagent pushbutton and more. It is surely very impressive both in performance and features, making it one of the best deals for home users that need expandable storage as well as access. By contrast, the best seagate can muster is 10tb of storage from the singledrive backup plus hub amazon.
Ac adapters free delivery possible on eligible purchases. I need to transfer a lot of data between a few machines. I spent ages trying to find this at the address given in the manual but on reading further it seems you simply need to type goflexhome. Copy files from the computer to the drive and also retain them on the computer. Wd elements 2tb vs seagate goflex 2tb ars technica.
Seagate announces its latest in external hard drives, the seagate backup plus family of external hard drives that replaces the goflex lineup. After reimaging i tried to access some of the files i saved on my external hard drive, but no matter what i tried i could not get access to the files. Seagate freeagent desk st315005fda2e1rk and western digital my book essential wdbaaf0015hbknesn its hard to find accurate specs on them. Backup plus and goflex desk thunderbolt software for mac. Move files from the computer to the external drive. Sep 02, 2011 western digital or seagate goflex 1tb external hdd by grv05 sep 2, 2011 10. I like the idea of being able to change the hard drive on my own, something the seagate doesnt make easy.
Some people i know refuse to warranty their hard drives because they think other people will get their used platters after the drive is refurbished and go to the trouble to recover the former data to steal. Please see our goflex home remote access shutdown article for more details after december 31st, 2018. Performance raw drives battle of the 4 tb nas drives. The western digital mybook 500gb triple interface usb,fw400,fw800 vs. My book av dvr expander, studio, live, mac, elements, western digital wd tv live. List of tested usb hard drives and printers for the linksys smart wi. My own preference right now is for hgst, but that brand has been taken over by western digital, so whether its history of superior quality will continue is uncertain.
Seagate expansion 1tb external or western digital 1tb my book. Granted, my experience might not reflect a representative sample, but ive seen enough chaos and suffering caused by seagate hardware to avoid it whenever possible. Seagate freeagent, and western digital wd my passport and elements hard drives. Seagate goflex desk external 1tb drive not accessible. Keep in mind that these storage drives are mechanical, same as used within computers, and so subject to breakdowns due to aging.
I have a spare wd mybook enclosure and a spare 500gb seagate sata drive. Western digital caviar green 3tb and my book essential 3tb. I have 3 wd and 1 seagate, and no problems with any so far. Anyall advice on choosing between the two is welcomed. So im in the market for a new external hd to backup my files obviously and two specific drives came to my attention. My main question is, will the seagate offer better performance than the wd elements. I receive a message unable to enumerate objects in the container access denied when i try to change permissions to the folder goflex x drive.
They dont have hardware encryption at least the usb3. Bensn ac to dc 12v western digital wd toshiba seagate power adapter cord cable for. I honestly doubt theres a difference as theyre relatively the same price usually. My question is that it seems as if i can only put a wd drive in the mybook enclosure. I think the seagate is 7200 rpm with a 32mb cache, and i cant find any numbers for western digital. If you dont intend to use the drive with other adapters it can be reformatted and the software is not needed.
The wd black cost significantly more, but comes with a 5 year warranty. Western digital or seagate goflex 1tb external hdd by grv05 sep 2, 2011 10. Goflex home network storage system seagate support us. Seagate stam2000200 2tb freeagent goflex wireless home. In fact, the differences between western digital, hitachi, and seagate drives is the stuff a college course could be scheduled around for those wishing to go deep. Well wd was in the past slightly better than seagate, but it might have changed. Off the top of my head no, but the green series for western digital have a green accent on them. In the world of external storage the upgrade path is obvious. Wd my cloud 2tb personal cloud storage from a trusted and recognizable hard drive brand western digital comes this xbox looking quality lowcost entrylevel network storage device. This item bovke protective case for seagate expansion desktop,western digital wd my book elements desktop external hard drive usb 3. This item bovke protective case for seagate expansion desktop,western digital wd my bookelements desktop external hard drive usb 3.
Wd my book is a very popular and one of the more expensive options. Wd my book essentials 3tb posted in external hardware. Seagate goflex connected, icons visible, folders shown as empty after windows 10 upgrade from windows 7, my goflex files are not accessible. Seagate freeagent 500gb, esata, fw400 which should i get. Seagate refines goflex drives into backup plus cnet. Unable to detect seagate freeagent goflex external drive. Buy 12v power adapter supply compatible wd western digital my book essential, seagate expansion srd0sd1 srd00f2 backup plus srd0sd0 central goflex freeagent external hard drive power cord. Cumpara hdd extern seagate freeagent go flex 1tb, 3. It seems that when i put that drive in the mybook enclosure it does not mount. Thinking the enclosure was bad, i put in a wd drive to test it and it mounts just fine.
The seagate goflex satellite is a portable wireless hard drive that lets you enjoy. Seagate expansion vs seagate backup plus hub vs wd. The my book is reliable, fast, and less expensive than the other desktop. So im debating between the western digital elements 2tb usb 2. Wd mycloud vs seagate personnal cloud vs other home nas. Make sure this fits by entering your model number usb 3. Feedback needed on seagate skyhawk versus wd purple.
But i am having an issue of it not finding my seagate goflex network drive as network share so i can take advantage of the dashboard. The performance of the drive wasnt anything out of the. It gets pretty warm with big file transfers but handles them like a champ. Mar 19, 2017 well i think its not secure at all, when they say my cloud you still have to createset up a usernamepassword on thier website ie wd. Dec 02, 2015 my book drives encrypt everything on the drive even if you dont specify a password. Goflex desk external drive support seagate support middle. Seagate goflex connected, icons visible, folders shown as. The 8 tb version of the western digital my book offers reliability, fast transfer. If you value a longer warranty then wd black are the way to go. Seagate fa goflex desk external hardrive doesnt show in my computer i reimaged my computer because i was having a whole bunch of trubble with it no of which really matter now. A bootable external device supported by mac os x, the mybook thunderbolt. I might be a technology neophyte when it comes to data. For additional information about using the goflex home after 123118, please see our support article here. My cd drive doesnt work on my computer so i headed to the website to download the setup program for mac.
53 1188 742 1100 963 1033 989 961 27 961 176 274 220 514 320 1638 237 697 1368 944 1637 1300 62 374 732 847 748 330 1453 1396 1163 360 686 762 663 292 1190 84 589 797 587 1138 1145